Between Chaos and Cosmic Order The Ambivalent Disposition of Matter in Middle Platonism

PDF
Published: Nov 29, 2024
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12681/dia.39532
Keywords:
Μiddle Platonism Demiurge matter Ploutarch Numenius Alcinous Apuleius
Stavros Dimakopoulos
Department of Philosophy, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Abstract

In Timaeus (30a ff.), Plato presents matter as a passive principle, inherently predisposed to disorder, subject to mechanistic necessity, and apparently devoid of any volition or predisposition towards the Demiurge. This cosmological framework, however, is not uniformly embraced by Middle Platonists. Instead, three divergent conceptions of matter emerge: one aligned with Plato’s notion of passivity, another in which matter resists the Demiurge with malevolence, and a third where it actively seeks union with the intelligible realm. This study pursues two primary objectives: first, to explore the ontological status and disposition of matter in relation to the intelligible within Middle Platonic thought; second, to elucidate why matter assumes such antithetical attributes.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Articles
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Ι. Primary sources
Aristotle. Physics, Volume I: Books 1-4. Translated by P. H. Wicksteed, F. M. Cornford. Loeb Classical Library 228, Harvard University Press 1957.
Beaujeu J., Apulée, Opuscules philosophiques (Du dieu de Socrate, Platon et sa doctrine, Du monde) et fragments, Les Belles Lettres 1973.
Des Places É., Numénius Fragments, Les Belles Lettres 1973.
Des Places É. Atticus. Fragments, Les Belles Lettres 1977.
Lakmann M.-L., Platonici minores, 1. Jh. v. Chr. – 2. Jh. n. Chr. Prosopographie. Fragmente und Testimonien mit deutscher Übersetzung, Brill 2017.
Pierre L., Albinos: Épitomé (Didascalicus), Les Belles Lettres 1945.
Plato. Theaetetus. Sophist. Translated by Harold North Fowler. Loeb Classical Library 123, Harvard University Press 1921.
Plato. Lysis. Symposium. Gorgias. Translated by W. R. M. Lamb. Loeb Classical Library 166, Harvard University Press 1925.
Plato. Statesman. Philebus. Ion. Translated by Harold North Fowler, W. R. M. Lamb. Loeb Classical Library 164, Harvard University Press 1925.
Plato. Laws, Volume II: Books 7-12. Translated by R. G. Bury. Loeb Classical Library 192, Harvard University Press 1926.
Plato. Timaeus. Critias. Cleitophon. Menexenus. Epistles. Translated by R. G. Bury. Loeb Classical Library 234, Harvard University Press 1929.
Plutarch. Moralia, Volume V: Isis and Osiris. The E at Delphi. The Oracles at Delphi No Longer Given in Verse. The Obsolescence of Oracles. Translated by Frank Cole Babbitt. Loeb Classical Library 306, Harvard University Press 1936.
Plutarch. Moralia, Volume VII: On Love of Wealth. On Compliancy. On Envy and Hate. On Praising Oneself Inoffensively. On the Delays of the Divine Vengeance. On Fate. On the Sign of Socrates. On Exile. Consolation to His Wife. Translated by Phillip H. De Lacy, Benedict Einarson. Loeb Classical Library 405, Harvard University Press 1959.
Plutarch. Moralia, Volume IX: Table-Talk, Books 7-9. Dialogue on Love. Translated by Edwin L. Minar, F. H. Sandbach, W. C. Helmbold. Loeb Classical Library 425, Harvard University Press 1961.
Plutarch. Moralia, Volume XIII: Part 1: Platonic Essays. Translated by Harold Cherniss. Loeb Classical Library 427, Harvard University Press 1976.
II. Secondary literature
Baltes M., “Γέγονεν (Platon Tim. 28b7): Ist die Welt real entstanden oder nicht?”, in: Algra K. – van der Horst P. W. – Runia D. (eds.), Polyhistor: Studies in the History and Historiography of Ancient Philosophy Presented to Jaap Mansfeld on His Sixtieth Birthday. Philosophia antiqua, v. 72, Brill, Leiden 1996.
Boys-Stones G., Platonist Philosophy 80 BC to AD 250: An Introduction and Collection of Sources in Translation. Cambridge 2018: Cambridge University Press.
Brisson L., Le même et l’autre dans la structure ontologique du Timée de Platon: Un commentaire systématique du Timée de Platon. Paris 1974: Klincksieck.
Broadie S., Nature and Divinity in Plato’s Timaeus. Cambridge 2012: Cambridge University Press.
Buganza J., “La metafísica de Numenio”, Studium: filosofía y teología, 47, 2021, pp. 5-20.
Cherniss H., Aristotle’s Criticism of Plato and the Academy. Baltimore 1944: The John Hopkins University Press.
Cornford F., Plato’s Cosmology: The Timaeus of Plato. Indianapolis 1937: Hackett.
Diels H. – Kranz W., Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker: Griechisch und deutsch. Hildesheim 1952: Weidmann.
Dillon J., The Middle Platonists. A Study of Platonism, 80 B.C. to A.D. 220. London 1996: Duckworth.
Dillon J., The Roots of Platonism. The Origins and Chief Features of a Philosophical Tradition. Cambridge – New York 2019: Cambridge University Press.
Di Stefano E., La triade divina in Numenio: Un’ anticipazione della teologia neoplatonica. Symbolon 38. Catania 2010: CUECM.
Dörrie H., “Die Frage nach dem Tranzendenten in Mittelplatonismus”, in: Dodds E. R. et al. (eds.), Entretiens sur l’Antiquité Classique 5. Les sources de Plotin, Fondation Hardt, Geneva 1960.
Dörrie H. – Baltes M., Der Platonismus in der Antike, 4: Die philosophische Lehre des Platonismus. Einige grundlegende Axiome/Platonische Physik (im antiken Verständnis) I. Bausteine 101-124: Text, Übersetzung, Kommentar. Stuttgart - Bad Cannstatt 1996: Frommann-Holzboog.
Ferrari F., “La generazione precosmica e la struttura della materia in Plutarco”, Museum Helveticum, 53: 1, 1996, pp. 45-55.
Ferrari F., “Separazione asimmetrica e causalità eidetica nel Timeo”, in: Napolitano Valditara L. M. (ed.), La sapienza di Timeo. Riflessioni a margine del Timeo di Platone, Vita e Pensiero, Milan 2007.
Ferrari F., “Materia, movimento, anima e tempo prima della nascita dell’universo: Plutarco e Attico sulla cosmologia del Timeo”, in: Coda E. – Martini Bonadeo C. (eds.), De l’Antiquité tardive au Moyen Âge: Études de logique aristotélicienne et de philosophie grecque, syriaque, arabe et latine offertes à Henri Hugonnard-Roche, Libraire Philosophique J. Vrin, Paris, 2014.
Ferrari F., “Il dibattito antico intorno all’origine del male: Platone e la tradizione platonica”, in: Merlini F. – Bernardini R. (eds.), The World and its Shadow. Eranos Yearbook 2015-2016, Daimon Verlag, Einsiedeln 2017.
Frazier F., “À propos de l’influence de la comédie dans l’Érotikos: un réexamen de la notion de ‘dialogue dramatique,”, in: Casanova A. (ed.), Plutarco e l’età ellenistica. Atti del convegno internazionale di studi, Firenze, 23-24 settembre 2004, Università degli studi di Firenze, Dipartimento di scienze dell’antichità ‘Giorgio Pasquali’, Florence 2005.
Guthrie W. K. C., A History of Greek Philosophy, Volume V: The Later Plato and the Academy. Cambridge 1978: Cambridge University Press.
Hackforth R., “Plato’s Theism”, The Classical Quarterly, 30: 1, 1936, pp. 4-9.
Ilievski V., “The Demiurge and His Place in Plato’s Metaphysics and Cosmology”, in: Vázquez D. – Ross A. (eds.), Time and Cosmology in Plato and the Platonic Tradition, Brill, Leiden, 2022.
Johansen T. K., “Why the Cosmos Needs a Craftsman: Plato, Timaeus 27d5-29b1”, Phronesis, 59: 4, 2014, pp. 297-320.
Jorgenson C., “Responsibility, Causality and Will in the Timaeus”, in: Jorgenson C. –Karfík F. – Špinka Š. (eds.), Plato’s Timaeus. Proceedings of the Tenth Symposium Platonicum Pragense; Brill’s Plato Studies Series, 5, Brill, Leiden 2021.
Jourdan F., “La matière à l’origine du mal chez Numénius (Fr. 43 et 52 Des Places)”, Philosophie antique: Problèmes, Renaissances, Usages, 14, 2014, pp. 185-235.
Kenney J. P., “Numenius and the Degrees of Divinity”, in: Kenney J. P. (ed.), Mystical Monotheism: A Study in Ancient Platonic Theology, Brown University Press, Hannover 1991.
Leinkauf T. – Steel C. (eds.), Plato’s Timaeus and the foundations of cosmology in Late Antiquity, the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Leuven 2005: Leuven University Press.
Lisi F. L., “Los tres niveles de la divinidad en Numenio de Apamea”, Cuadernos de Filosofia, 26-27, 1977, pp. 111-130.
Maso S., “Providential Disorder in Plato’s Timaeus?”, Peitho. Examina Antiqua, 9: 1, 2018, pp. 37-52.
Menn S. P., Plato on God as Nous. Carbondale 1995: Southern Illinois University Press.
Mohr R. D., “Disorderly Motion in Plato’s ‘Statesman’”, Phoenix, 35: 3, 1981, pp. 199-215.
Morrow G. R., “Necessity and Persuasion in Plato’s Timaeus”, The Philosophical Review, 59: 2, 1950, pp. 147-163.
Müller G., “La doctrina de los tres dioses de Numenio”, Archai: The Origins of Western Thought, 5, 2010, pp. 29-35.
Neschke-Hentschke Α. (ed.), Le Timée de Platon. Contributions à l’histoire de sa réception. Platos Timaios. Beiträge zu seiner Rezeptionsgeschichte. Bibliothèque Philosophique de Louvain 53. Louvain-la-neuve 2000: Peeters.
O’Brien C. S., The Demiurge in Ancient Thought: Secondary Gods and Divine Mediators. Cambridge 2015: Cambridge University Press.
Pleše Z., “Evil and Its Sources in Gnostic Traditions”, in: Jourdan F. – Hirsch-Luipold R. (eds.), Die Wurzel allen Übels Vorstellungen über die Herkunft des Bösen und Schlechten in der Philosophie und Religion des 1.–4. Jahrhunderts. Ratio Religionis Studien III, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen 2014.
Taylor A. E., A Commentary on Plato’s Timaeus. Oxford 1928: Clarendon Press.
Thévenaz P., L’Âme du monde, le Devenir et la Matière chez Plutarque (Collection d’Études anciennes). Paris 1938: Les Belles Lettres.
Tzamalikos P., “The Concept of Ύλη (Matter) in Plato’s Timaeus”, Philosophia. Yearbook of the Research Center for Greek Philosophy at the Academy of Athens, 27-28, 1997/1998, pp. 131-141.
Vlastos G., “Creation in the Timaeus: Is it a fiction?”, in: Allen R. E. (ed.), Studies in Plato’s Metaphysics, Routledge, London-New York 1965.
Vlastos G., Plato’s Universe. Seattle 1975: University of Washington Press.