Interpretation of a difficult heritage about the internal exile of political opponents in Greece. The cases of the Concentration Camps of islands Ai-Stratis, Chios and Anafi.


Published: Mar 31, 2024
Keywords:
Difficult cultural heritage Political prisoners Concentration Camp Ai-Stratis Chios Anafi
Myrto Marini
Abstract

The practice of internal exile in Greece, inaugurated during the aftermaths of the National Schism (1915-17) and continued by the Pangalos’ dictatorship, was generalized after the vote of the anticommunist “Idionymo” law of the liberal Venizelos’ government (1929), during the Metaxas dictatorship (1936-1940), during the Greek civil war (1946-49) and the political repression that followed and finally during the Greek Junta (1967-74) and applied mostly against the communists and other political opponents. The political transition of the Metapolitefsi (1974) marked the end of this practice, but the decades of turning dozens of Greek islands into places of exile and “disciplinary camps” for the “enemies of the State” is something that have created a multitude of political and social experiences of great historical importance. Though, this is a kind of “difficult cultural heritage” to deal with for the local communities and for the Greek State itself. The obvious duty to preserve and promote the memory of these historical sites is undermined, on the one hand by the fear to revive political conflicts from the past that still appear thorny, and on the other hand by the fear that this preservation and promotion would darken the sunny and pleasant brand name needed by the islands in question for tourist purposes. Thus, the exile sites on Greek islands have been consigned to oblivion, an oblivion that recent efforts to transform such sites of memory into museums and to promote them, try to overcome. Using an on-the-spot investigation at the exile sites on three of these islands (Ai-Stratis, Chios and Anafi) and desk research of relevant literature (books, historical achieves, photographic records, oral testimonies) the present article reconstitutes the very hard but also very rich in cultural forms of resistance and in creativity life of the exiles, stresses the importance of these three exile sites for the Greek political history and also for the local history and identity and advocates for more state action aiming the preservation of this heritage.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Articles
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Apostolopoulou, N. (1979), Den doulono… den apografo, [I don’t declare, I don’t sign], Sichroni Epoxi, Athens. ISBN: 9780002245227
Birtles, B. (2002), Exoristoi sto Aigaio, Afigimata Politikou kai Taxidiotikou Endiaferontos, [Exiles in the Aegean, Narratives of political and travel interest], Filistor, Athens. ISBN: 9789603690665.
Black, G. (2010), To Elkistiko Mouseio, Mouseia kai Episkeptes [The Attractive Museum, Museums and Visitors], Piraeus Bank Group Cultural Foundations, Athens. ISBN: 978960244117
Burström, M. (2009), Selective Remembrance: Memories of a Second War Refugee Camp in Sweden, Norwegian Archaeological Review, 1502-7678, pp 42. Doi:10.12681/dac.25913
Carman, J. & Carman, P. (2001) Beyond Military Archaeology Battlefields as a Research Resource, in Freeman, P. & Pollard, T. (Eds.), Fields of Conflict: progress and prospects in battlefield archaeology, Proceedings of a conference held in the Department of Archaeology, University of Glasgow, April 2000, BAR International Series, Oxford, 958, pp 275-281.
Droumpouki, Α., Μ. (2014), Mnimeia tis Lithis, Ichni tou B’Pagkosmiou Polemou stin Ellada ais tin Europi [Monuments to oblivion: traces of the Second World War in Greece and Europe], Polis, Athens. ISBN: 978-960-435-440-5
Gavriilidou, N. (2006), Stratopeda ginaikon, Xios – Trikeri – Makronisos – Ai Stratis 1948-1954, [Womens’ camps, Chios – Trikeri- Makronisos – Ai Stratis 1948-1954], Alfeios, Athens. ISBN: 960-87931-8-1
Gavrilidis, K. (1997), Imerologio Anafis, [Anafi’s diary], Entos, ISBN: 960847212Χ
Georgiadou, Z., Florou, V., &Georgiadou, I., I. (2021). Contemporary condemnation of memory. Global Journal of Sociology: Current Issues,11(1), 20–27. https:doi.org/10.18844/gjs.v11i1.5449
Gritzonas, K. (1985), Kokkinoi drapetes 1920-1040, [Red runaways 1920-1940], Glaros. ISBN: 9780002750462
Hatzinikolaou, T. (2010), Istorika Tekmiria kai Prosopika Viomata: I Proklisi ton Mouseion Sigchronis Istorias [Historical Documents and Personal Experiences: The Challenge of Contemporary History Museums], Tetradia Mouseiologias [Museology Notebooks], issue 7, Kaleidoscope, pp 43-48.
Kamarinou, K. (2005), Ta Petrina Penipistimia, O Agonas gia ti Morfosi stis Filakes kai tis Eksories, 1924-1974, [The University of Stone, The Struggle for Education in Political Prisons and Exiles, 1924-1974], Athens, Sichroni Epoxi. ISBN: 978-224-978-1.
Kaplan, F., E., S. (2012), Kataskevazontas kai Anaskevazontas Ethnikes Taftotites [Constructing and Reconstructing National Identities], in Macdonald, S. (ed.), Mouseio kai Mouseiakes Spoudes. Enas Pliris odigos [Museum and Museum Studies. A Complete Guide], Piraeus Bank Group Cultural Foundations, Athens. ISBN: 978-960-244-155-8
Kazakos, K. (2013), Ai-Stratis, H Maxi Tis Pinas Ton Politikon Eksoriston. Ximonas 1941-1942, [Ai-Stratis, The Struggle Against the Starvation of Political Exiles], Sichroni Epoxi, Athens. ISBN: 978-451-161-7
Kenna, K. (2004), I koinoniki organosi, Politikoi kratoumenoi sto Mesopolemo, [The social organisation of exile, Greek political detainees in the interwar], Alexandreia. ISBN: 9789602212714
Koundouros, R. (1978), I asfalia tou kathestotos, Politikkoi kratoumenoi- Ektopiseis kai taxeis stin Ellada 1924-74, [Security of the regime, Political prisoners – Expulsions and classes in Greece 1924-74], Kastaniotis, Athens.
Leuka, E. (1964), Ginaikes stin exoria, [Women in exile], Politikes kai Logotexnikes ekdoseis.
Liakos, Α. (2007), Pos to Parelthon Ginetai Istoria? [How does the past become history?], Polis, Athens. ISBN: 9789604351534
Macdonald, S. (2009a), Difficult Heritage. Negotiating the Nazi Past in Nuremberg and Beyond, Routledge. ISBN: 9780415419925
Macdonald, S. (2009b), Unsettling Memories: Intervention and Controversy over Difficult Heritage, in Peralta, E., Anico, M. (Eds.), Heritage and Identity. Museum Meanings, Routledge, pp 93-104.
Macdonald, S. (2010), I Istoria os Koinoniko Zitima: Erminevontas ti “Diskoli” Klironomia [History as a Social Issue: Interpreting the “Difficult” Heritage”], in Tetradia Mouseiologias [Museology Notebooks], issue 7, Kaleidoscope, pp 14-15.
Macdonald, S. (2013), Memory Lands. Heritage and Identity in Europe Today, Routledge. Doi:10.4000/temoigner.1013
Masoura, Ε. & Kargopoulos, F. (2008), Mnimes tou Polemou kai oi Polemoi tis Mnimis [Memories of War and Wars of Memory], in Van Boeschoten, R., Τ. Vervenioti, Ε., Voutira, Β., Dalkavoukis (eds.), Mnimes kai Lithi tou Ellinikou Emfiliou Polemou [Memories and Oblivion of the Greek Civil War], Epikentro, Thessaloniki. ISBN: 978-960-458-165-8
Mastroleon-Zerva, M. (1985), Exoristes, Chios – Trikeri – Makronisos, [Exiles, Chios – Trikeri – Makronisos], Sichroni Epoxi, Athens.
Μichaelidou, Μ. (2002), Mouseio: Poreia kai Prooptikes pros ton 21ο Aiona [Museum: Course and Perspectives towards the 21st Century], in Diepistimonikes Prosegkiseis sti Mouseiaki Agogi [Interdisciplinary Approaches to Museum Education], Athens.
Mpartziotas, B. (1978), Stis filakes kai tis exories, [In prisons and exiles], Kastanioti, Athens.
Mpirkas, K. (1966), Kato apo ti bota tis diktatorias, Selides tou agona 1936-1940, [Under the boot of the dictatorship, Pages of the struggle 1936-1940], Melissa, Aegina.
Pantzou, Ν. (2010), Foreis Travmatikis Istorikis Mnimis: to Mouseio Politikon Exoriston Ai Strati stin Athina [Vehicles of Traumatic Historical Memory: the Museum of the Ai Stratis Political Exiles in Athens], Tetradia Mouseiologias [Museology Notebooks], issue 7, Kaleidoscope, pp 49-54.
Portelli, A. (1991), What Makes Oral History Different?, στο Portelli, A. (ed.), The Death of Luigi Trastulli and Other Stories: Form and Meaning in Oral History, Sunny Press, pp 52.
Staveri, O. (2006), To martiriko trigono ton exoriston ginaikon, [The martyred triangle of exiled women], Paraskinio, Athens. ISBN: 9789608342460
Theodorou, V. (2006), Stratopeda Gynaikon – Chios, Trikeri, Makronisos, Ai-Stratis, [Women’s Camps – Chios, Trikeri, Makronisos, Ai-Stratis], Alfeios, Athens. ISBN: 960-87931-8-1
Tsellos, T. (2002), Politistiki Zoi kai Drastiriotita sto Stratopedo ton Politikon Eksoriston tou Ai-Strati (1950-1962), [Cultural life and Activity in Camp of Political Exiles of Ai-Startis (1950-1962], p.35 ISBN: 2229607221467
Tzamaloukas, N. (2002), Enas Golgothas gia ti lefteria, [A Calvary for freedom], Sichroni Epoxi, Athens. ISBN: 9789604514113
Varnalis, K. (2014), Ai-Stratis, Thimimata Eksorias, [Ai-Stratis, Exile’s Memories], Kastanioti, Athens. ISBN: 978-960-03-5702-8
Voglis, P. (2002) Becoming A Subject, Political Prisoners During the Greek Civil War, Berghahn Books, New York.
Xatzidimos, G. (1990), Simiosis apo tin istoria tou ergatikou kinimatos, [Notes from the history of the labor movement], Athens.