Question about the Ethics of Yalta Agreements in 1945. Archaeology of Power in Historiographical Discourses

Published: Oct 31, 2019
ethics historical events etiquette archaeology of knowledge the Yalta conference
Oleg Konstantinovich Shevchenko
The Crimea (Yalta) Conference is by all means an extremely complex historical event. Any attempt to estimate its role and significance without analyzing its ethical components would unavoidably result in unduly simplifying the historical reality of the time, as well as in forming erroneous assumptions that would necessarily be used in the analysis of the causes of Cold War. A thorough examination will show that as far as the ‘ethical’ issues are concerned, there are significant developments with regard to general methodology, as well as its application to the sources. Generations of historians who have addressed the issue of Yalta Conference, although they have not been able to form a scientific, distinct ‘ethical’ tradition so far, have developed all the necessary prerequisites for its establishment. This is evident in the possibility of segmenting the issue in two parts on the one hand, and on the other in the availability of sufficient sources, structured databases, and selected outstanding works. Still, there are no studies about the Yalta Conference so far that address exclusively ethical issues concerning ‘good’ and ‘evil,’ ‘morality,’ ‘duty,’ and ‘honor.’ Although historiographical approaches are to a large extent dependent upon ethical viewpoints, in the case of Yalta agreements so far there have been no techniques available, so as to connect historical accounts with ideology, and historical facts with their philosophical background. In a sense, the situation is quite the same as it is with the study of prehistory: although there is an abundance of data and facts that can be primarily processed, there are no methodological guidelines, nor any devices to classify and explain them. This is also typical for any question raised about the ethics of the Yalta agreements in February 1945.
Article Details
  • Section
  • Articles
Download data is not yet available.
Author Biography
Oleg Konstantinovich Shevchenko, V. I. Vernadsky Crimean Federal University

PhD in Social Philosophy.

Associate Professor, Humanities and Education Science Academy (Yalta), Department of philosophy and social Sciences

Doroshenko, N. Elena Shamrin, A. Oleg, Yurtchenko, V. Sergey, eds. Krymskaja konferentsija 1945 goda v vospominanijakh i dokumentakh. Simferopolʹ: Krym, 2006.
Foreign Relations of the United States. Diplomatic Papers: The Conferences at Malta and Yalta 1945. Washington: United States Government Printing Office, 1955.
Gibianskiy, Ja. Leonid. “Vopros o Bolgarii, Rumynii i Vengrii na Krymskoy konferentsii.” Sovetskoe slavjanovedenie 2 (1982): 9-22.
Gromyko, A. Andrey, red. Sovetskiy Soyuz na mezhdunarodnykh konferencijakh perioda Velikoy Otečestvennoy vojny 1941-1945 gg. Krymskaja konferenkhija rukovoditeley trekh soyuznykh derzhav – SSSR, SSHA i Velikobritanii (4-11 fevr. 1945 g.): sbornik dokumentov. Moskva: Politizdat, 1979.
Harbutt, J. Fraser. Yalta 1945: Europe and America at the Crossroads. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2014.
Narotchnitskaja, A. Natalʹja, ed. Jalta-45. Natchertanija novogo mira. Moskva: Vetche, 2010.
Peters, Gerhard, and John T. Woolley. The American Presidency Project. “Reagan, Ronald. Statement on the 40th Anniversary of the Yalta Conference, February 5, 1985.” Accessed 29 May 2018.
Plokhy, M. Serhii. Yalta: The Price of Peace. New York: Penguin, 2010.
Russell D., Buhitte. Decisions at Yalta. An Appraisal of Summit Diplomacy. Wilmington: Scholarly Resources, 1986.
Shamrin, A. Oleg. “Ardennskaja operatsija i ee vlijanie na pozicii soyuznikov na Krymskoj konferentsii.” Istoritcheskoe nasledie Kryma 9 (2005): 9-11.
Shevchenko, K. Oleg. “Ètitcheskie voprosy Krymskoy konferentsii 1945 g. s totchki zrenija filosofii istorii.” Kulʹtura narodov Pričernomorʹja 274 (2014): 95-97.
Shevchenko, K. Oleg. “Jaltinskaja konferentsija 1945 g.: v gnoseologitcheskom pole filosofii.” Kulʹtura narodov Pritchernomorʹja 259 (2013): 195-199.
Shevchenko, K. Oleg. “Source Study of the Crimean Conference 1945: Scientific Ethics Issue.” Вісник Львівського університету Серія Міжнародні відносини 35 (2014): 44-50.
Shevchenko, K. Oleg. “Yalta-45: Ukrainian Science Historiographic Realia in Globalization and Universalism Era.” Science and Education, a New Dimension. Humanities and Social Science 1, no. 2 (2013): 39-42.
Slavinskiy, N. Boris. Jaltinskaja konferentsija i problema “severnykh territorij.” Moskva: Novina, 1996.
Stettinius, Edvard. Roosevelt and the Russians, The Yalta Conference. Garden City, New York: Doubleday, 1949.
Wittmer, Felix. The Yalta Betrayal. Data on the Decline and Fall of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Caldwell: The Caxton Printers, 1961.
Yurtchenko, V. Sergey. Jaltinskaja konferentsija 1945 goda: khronika sozdanija novogo mira. Simferopolʹ: Krym, 2005.