Public Procurement and Mediation to Facilitate Procedures for the preservation of World's Cultural Heritage

Pdf
Published: Jul 17, 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12681/ta.34810
Keywords:
public procurement , mediation , world’s ancient and religious heritage monuments
Maria Sideri
Attorney at the Court of Appeal, LLM Legal Representative at the Hellenic Union of Mediators
https://orcid.org/0009-0007-6203-1098
Abstract



All levels of legislation from national rules to international Treaties include provisions for heritage procurement and alternative dispute resolution. Each law has got its own scope and field of application: some of those are obligatory, with direct effect and supreme. Practitioners thus need to apply the right texts for the conclusion of public contracts and for the resolution of their disputes. Mediation is being proposed as a very modern and flexible tool for disputes’ settlements arising in a contest. Some examples of successful public procurement may be found here and a superficial approach to the Hagias-Sofia project.




Article Details
  • Section
  • Uni and interdisciplinary approach for the sustainable preservation of Cultural Heritage
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Io. Tsiptsiou-Karimpali, ‘The protection of ancient monuments and of cultural heritage under the light of Greek law 3028/2002’, Sakkoulas eds., 2004, esp. pp.15-100. Details on distinguishing between movable and immovable monuments, on the different historical periods, on ecclesiastical and ancient monuments etc.
A. Prepis, ‘Restoration and management of world heritage cultural sites: problems and religious tourism – challenges and perspectives’, in “Transdisciplinary multispectral modeling and cooperation for the preservation of cultural heritage”, hereinafter as ‘the Conference’*. Revised selected papers Vol.1-Part II, pp. 239-261.
Prof. Sue Arrowsmith, detailed bibliographyinhttps://www.nottingham.ac.uk/law/people/sue.arrowsmith
See for example in https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/single-market/public- procurement_en, then for the Government Procurement Agreement of the World Trade Organisation https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/gproc_e/gp_gpa_e.htm, and the Uncitral model law in https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/procurement
P. Trepte, ‘Public Procurement in the EU – a practitioner’s guide’, Oxford Uni. Press, 2007. Analysis in pp. 89-134 and then pp. 319-480.
Hannah Segal, in https://psychoanalysis.org.uk/articles/the-mind-of-the- fundamentalistterrorist-not-learning-from-experience-hiroshima-the-gulf-war ‘...the combination of the military and the religious is the most psychotic assumption, that may dominate human groups...’
J. Poulios ‘on the greatest challenge in the management of living religious heritage: linking the authenticity of tourist experiences to the authenticity of religious tradition’, in the Conference’s Vol 1-Part II, pp. 262-271, ‘religious communities are promoted as a group with the highest responsibility in the operation and management of their sites’.
European Court of Justice, case C-225/1996 ‘Nord Pas-de-Calais’ (esp. par. 46-54).
European Commission Notice on the notion of State-Aid as referred to in Article 107 of the
Treaty on the functioning of the EU. OJ C 262/2016.
B. Burnham, ‘Towards a new heritage financing tool for sustainable development’, in the Conference’s Vol. 1-Part II, pp. 275-288. Also, see the organisationwww.europanostra.org
E. Mouameletzi, ‘Commenting on ECJ C280/00, the Altmark case’, DiSKE issue 1/2004, pp. 42-54, same author and journal, issue 2/2004 ‘Recovery of unlawful state-aids’ pp. 149- 160.
See ECJ the ‘Le Mans’ judgement, C-340/2002. Further details on design contests in P. Trepte pp. 232-234 and 401-404.
G. Trantas, ‘Framework Agreements – an introductory approach’, in “Public Procurement and State-Aid Law Review”, hereinafter “DiSKE”. Magazine from the Centre of International and European Economic Law, Thessaloniki, 2004-2015, www.cieel.gr. Issue 2/2008.
C.Boniotti,‘Publicbuilt,culturalheritagemanagement:thepublic-privatepartnership’,in Conference Vol.1-Part II, pp. 289-298. Also, S. Panagopoulos, ‘PPPs in Europe and Greece’, in DiSKE issue 3/2005, pp. 337-348.
the Conference Vol. 1-Part I: the project of the rehabilitation of Holy Sepulchre’s Holy Aedicule as a pilot multispectral, multidimensional, Novel Approach through transdisciplinary and co-operation in the protection of monuments, pp. 27-102. Also in Vol 2-Part I: Sustainable Preservation and Management lessons learnt on emblematic monuments, pp. 1-128.
in Conference Vol.1-Part II: chapter ‘Digital heritage’, pp.103-260. Also in conference Vol.2 the chapter on ‘Scientific innovations in the diagnosis and preservation of Cultural Heritage’, pp.1-50.
G. Padeletti ‘Heritage Resilience against climate events on site- HERACLES project” Mission and vision’, in Conference Vol. 1-Part II. In the same chapter St. Athanasiou ‘the Holy Sepulchre as a religious building. How the earthquakes, were the incentive to restore the Holy Sepulchre’.
K. Gogos, ‘the subject of a public contract following technical specifications’, in DiSKE, issue 3/2005, pp. 316-321. Also see, K. Siountri et al ‘The digitalization of the tangible cultural heritage and the related policy framework’, the Conference Vol.1-Part I, pp. 250- 260.
Io.Anastasopoulou‘MediationincivilandcommercialDisputes’,NomikiVivliothikieds., 2011. Further information in www.eledi.gr
Especially see the European directive 2008/52. On behalf of the United Nations there is variety on dispute resolution texts, mediation may be found in https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/mediation. The WTO panels in https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/disp_settlement_cbt_e/c8s1p1_e.htm
G.dePalo&L.d’Urso‘Achievingabalancedrelationshipbetweenmediationandjudicial proceedings’, DG for Internal Policies – citizens’ rights & Constitutional affairs, 2016, pp.9- 29.
See ECJ C-75/2016 Menini vs Banco Popolare, as well as the Alassini case in C-317- 320/2008 on the principle of effective judicial protection and the condition to attempt an out-of-Court dispute settlement.
E.g. in the Conference’s Vol. 1, Chapter 3 ‘Discussing resilience to climate change and natural hazards’, Pp. 351-423.
K. Cloke ‘Mediating dangerously: the frontiers of conflict resolution’, San Francisco, Jossey-Bass, 2001.
Conference Vol. 1-Part II ‘Reuse, circular economy and social participation as a leverage for the sustainable preservation and management of historic cities’, pp. 273-321. Also, in Conference’s Vol. 2 ‘Preservation, reuse and reveal of cultural heritage through sustainable land management. Rural and urban development to recapture the World in crisis through culture’, pp. 229-284.
As in reference [6] above, on the assault of feeling of security: ‘...from the superego of a nation to the trauma of another... not learning from the experience’.
M.Pelekanos&B.Ioannou,‘Educationandtrainingforthepreservationofculturalheritage, as a strategic aim of the department of Architecture – Frederick Uni. Of Cyprus’, in Conference Vol. 1-Part I, pp. 285-308.