The interventions for the main dome of Hagia Sophia throughout its history and a preservation proposal

PDF
Published: Jul 28, 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12681/ta.36467
Hasan Fırat Diker
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3156-3127
Mehmet Halis Günel
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9482-1744
Beyza Kapucu Güzelbulut
Abstract

Throughout its history, Hagia Sophia has faced seismic risks due to structural issues. The ambitious design led to the complete collapse of the main dome merely 21 years after its construction, and partial collapses occurred in the 10th and 14th centuries. Over time, the structure underwent various repairs and reinforcements. Following the collapse of the south-eastern section during the 1346 earthquake, flying buttresses were installed, attaching to the main dome from four directions. However, during the Fossati repairs (1847-1849), these elements were removed and replaced with iron beams, framing the upper perimeter of the pedestal supporting the main dome. The current challenges faced by the main dome are primarily rooted in the design of the piers and arches rather than the dome itself. Since reconstructing these structural elements is impossible, efforts to address the dome's issues have concentrated on retrofitting the supporting system. This study critically assesses the current state of the main dome, examining past interventions. As a solution, it proposes reinforcing the main dome structure by installing a tension ring to enhance stability.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Digital Heritage - Holistic Approach
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Mungan, İ.: Mimar Sinan ve Kubbe Statiği [Architect Sinan and his dome statics]. In: Sönmez, Z. (ed.) Mimar Sinan Dönemi Türk Mimarlığı ve Sanatı [Turkish Architecture and Art in the Period of Architect Sinan], pp. 175-188. Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür yay., Istanbul (1988).
Diker, H. F.: Ayasofya ve Onarımları [Hagia Sophia and Its Repairs]. FSMVU yay., Istanbul (2016).
Mainstone, R. J.: Hagia Sophia. Thames & Hudson, Slovenia (2001).
Demirkent, I,: Bizans Tarihi Yazıları [Papers on Byzantine History]. Dünya Yayınevi, Istan-bul (2005).
Sakin, O.: Tarihsel Kaynaklarıyla İstanbul Depremleri [Istanbul Earthquakes in Historical Resources]. Kitabevi yay, Istanbul, (2002).
Çakmak, A.S., Taylor, R., Durukal E.: Justinianos Ayasofya’sının (İ.S. 537-558) İlk Kubbesinin Yapısal Konfigürasyonu Yapısal ve Yazısal Çözümlemeye Dayalı Bir Araştırma [The structural configuration of the first dome of Justinian’s Hagia Sophia(A.D. 537–558): An investigation based on structural and literary analysis]. Sanat Dünyamız 94, 175-181 (2005).
Müller-Wiener, W.: İstanbul’un Tarihsel Topograyası [Historical Topography of Istanbul]. Sayın, Ü. (tr.), Yapı Kredi Yayınları, Istanbul (2001).
Conant, K. J.: The first dome of St. Sophia and its rebuilding. American Journal of Archae-ology, 43 (4), 589–91 (1939).
Çakmak, A. S., Taylor, R., Durukal, E.: The structural configuration of the first dome of Justinian’s Hagia Sophia(A.D. 537–558): An investigation based on structural and literary analysis. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 29, 693–698 (2009).
Çakmak, A., Moropoulou, A., Mullen, C.: Interdisciplinary Study of Dynamic Behaviour and Earthquake Response of Hagia Sophia. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 14, 125-133 (1995).
Badmutyun Sdepanosi Asoghgan, pub. Garabed Şahnazaryan, Paris, (1859).
Fossati, G.: Aya Sofia Constantinople as Recently Restored by Order of H.M. The Sultan Abdul Mejid, London, (1852).
Ahunbay, Z.: Bir Dünya Mirasının Korunması: Ayasofya [Conservation of World Heritage: Hagia Sophia in Istanbul]. Uluslararası Katılımlı 6. Tarihi Yapıların Korunması ve Güçlendirilmesi Sempozyumu [6th Symposium on Conservation and Strengthening of His-torical Buildings with International Participation], pp. 37-46. Trabzon (2017).
Ülker Engineering and Consultancy. Earthquake Safety Determination and Repair and Rein-forcement Determination Project for Hagia Sophia Museum (1993).
Tanyeli, G., Tanyeli, U.: Ayasofya’da Strüktürel Demir Kullanımı [Structural Use of Iron in St. Sophia, Istanbul]. Sanat Tarihi Defterleri: 8, Metin Ahunbay’a Armağan Bizans Mimarisi Üzerine Yazılar, pp. 23-58 Istanbul, (2004),
Diker, H. F.:Belgeler Işığında Fossati’nin Ayasofya’da Yok Ettiği İzler ve Ayasofya’da Kullanılan Harç Üzerine Etimolojik ve Deneysel Bir Araştırma [The Traces Destroyed by Fossati in Hagia Sophia in the Light of Documents and an Etymological and Experimental Research on the Mortar Used in Hagia Sophia], KÜLTÜR VE TURIZM BAKANLIĞI 28. ARAŞTIRMA SONUÇLARI TOPLANTISI, vol. 2, pp. 251-62. Ankara (2011).
Ahunbay, Z.: Ayasofya Restorasyonu İçin Önaraştırmalar [Preliminary Research for the Restoration of Hagia Sophia]. Yapı, 177, 117-127 (1996).
Antoniadi, E. M.: Ekphrasis tes Hagias Sophias. vol. I (originally published Leipzig/Athens 1907–1909). Athenai: Ekdoseis V. Gregoriades (1983).
Istanbul Archaeological Museums Directorate Arşivi, 1936.
Photograph by Aras Neftçi, 2010.
CA [Turkish Republic Archive], 3932/30..18.1.1/20.49..13.
CA [Turkish Republic Archive], 5230/30..18.1.1/24.33..13.
Cumhuriyet, 12 May 1925; Cumhuriyet, 4 September 1926; Cumhuriyet, 30 January 1928.
Dabanlı, Ö., Tökmeci, K.: İstanbul Ayasofya ve Edirne Selimiye Camilerinin Kubbeleri ̇Hakkında Mukayeseli Bir Değerlendirme [A Comparave Analysis About the Domes of Istanbul Hagia Sophia and Edirne Selimiye Mosques]. In: Diker, H. F., Esmer, M., Dural, M. (eds.) INTERNATIONAL HAGIA SOPHIA SYMPOSIUM, pp. 613-638. FSMVU yay., Istanbul (2020).
Duppel, C.: Ingenieurwissenschaftliche Untersuchungen an der Hauptkuppel und den Hauptpfeilern der Hagia Sophia in Istanbul, KIT Scientific Publishing, Karlsruhe (2010).
Wenzel, F., Duppel, C.: Investigations into the Construction and Repair History of the Hagia Sophia. Ayasofya Müzesi Yıllığı [Annual of the Hagia Sophia Museum] no. 13, pp. 177-192, Istanbul (2010).
Erdik, M.: Earthquake Performance of Hagia Sophia. In: Diker, H. F., Esmer, M., Dural, M. (eds.) INTERNATIONAL HAGIA SOPHIA SYMPOSIUM, pp. 51-89, FSMVU pub., Istanbul (2020).
Diker, H.F.: Restoration of the Outer Treasury and exhibition of the Section of arms and ar-mours in Topkapı Palace Museum. Frontiers of Architectural Research 1(4), 365-374 (2012).