Are Conservation Principles being implemented in Historic cities or not?


Published: Apr 28, 2025
Keywords:
Historic Urban Landscape Heritage historic cities Urban Heritage, Heritage Conservation, Spatial Planning
Ioannis Kartsonakis
https://orcid.org/0009-0005-3560-1847
Rena Klabatsea
Abstract

This paper recommends eleven criteria regarding the conservation of urban heritage, through a review of UNESCO international standards for the protection of historic cities. When comparing these conservation standards with the current conditions of many historic cities, it seems that many of them have been already adopted in a haphazard manner. Therefore, a holistic reporting approach is required to demonstrate how efficiently Historic Urban Landscape is being preserved. This approach integrates also the heritage conservation into the sustainable urban development, preserving not only the quality of the built environment but also traditional productive resources and the daily lives of local residents. Furthermore, through a survey of one of the oldest cities in Europe, Argos in the Peloponnese has been chosen as a case study to implement a comprehensive conservation status report based on the aforementioned principles. Listed monuments, archaeological sites, historic districts, vernacular architecture, and other components of both intangible and tangible urban heritage have been assessed and organized within this framework. Therefore, by identifying valuable characteristics of the cities with their vulnerability signs, stakeholders from public services, civil society and private sector could be informed and participate in a policy-making process.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Spatial Planning
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Recommendation on the Safeguarding of the Beauty and Character of Landscapes & Sites, UNESCO (1962)
Recommendation on the Preservation of Cultural Property endangered by Public and Private Works, UNESCO (1968)
Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage, UNESCO (1972)
Recommendation on the Protection at National Level of the World Cultural & Natural Heritage, UNESCO (1972)
Recommendation on the Safeguarding the contemporary role of Historic Areas, UNESCO (1976)
Washington Charter: Conservation of Historic Towns and Urban Areas, ICOMOS (1987)
Convention concerning the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, UNESCO (2003)
Convention concerning the Protection of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions, UNESCO (2005)
Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape, UNESCO (2011)
Valetta Principles: Safeguarding & Management of Historic Cities, Towns & Urban Areas, CIVVIH (2011)
CULTURE URBAN FUTURE Global Report on Culture for Sustainable Urban Development, UNESCO (2016)
Loes Veldpaus, Julia Rey Perez, THE HUL GUIDEBOOK Managing heritage in dynamic and con-stantly changing urban environments, Ballarat & WHITRAP (2016)
New life for historic cities, the historic urban landscape approach explained, UNESCO (2013)
Resolutions of the International Symposium on the Conservation of Smaller Historic Towns, 4th ICOMOS General Assembly (1975)
Julia Rey Perez, 15The Application of the Recommendation on Historic Urban Landscape (HUL) in Cuenca – Ecuador. A new Approach to Cultural and Natural Heritage (2017)
Developing Historic Cities, Keys for understanding and taking action, A compilation of case studies on the conservation and management of historic cities, UNESCO (2014)
Sarah Al-Alawi, Robert Knippschild, Eva Battis-Schinker & Bettina Knoop, Linking Cultural Built Heritage and Sustainable Urban Development, Insights into Strategic Development Recommendations for the German-Polish Border Region, Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group ETH, 2022
S. Avgerinou Kolonias, A. Gomez, Ferrer Bayo, Eleven years after the Valletta Principles, Thema & Collecta CIVVIH – ICOMOS Symposium (2022)
Greek Antiquities Law No 4858 “Protection of Antiquities and Cultural Heritage in general” (2021)
Presidential Decree – Urban Planning “Designation of historic quarter and preservable premises in Ar-gos and building regulations” (1982)
Ministerial Decision No 1841 “Endorsement of General Development Plan in Municipality of Argos, Argolis Prefecture” (2010)
List of registered enterprises in Argos (commerce, manufacturing, services) – updated 2021, Argolis Chamber of Commerce and Industry (2023)
List of recent monuments under the jurisdiction of Ministry of Culture, Hellenic Republic, National Archive of Monuments, https://www.arxaiologikoktimatologio.gov.gr/en (2023)
List of preservable buildings under the jurisdiction of Ministry of Environment, Hellenic Republic (March, 2024)