Integrating perspectives from engineering ethics into the study of technology: A synthesis of research on critical cases


Published: Apr 9, 2024
Keywords:
engineering ethics technology ethics BART case Virginia Edgerton case whistleblowing
Konstantinos Konstantis
https://orcid.org/0009-0009-7196-3561
Thomas Tsakalakis
Abstract

Ethics play a crucial role in the work of engineers, and therefore in everyone’s life, from the field of artificial intelligence ethics to the fields of environmental ethics and biomedical ethics. Analyzing critical technology case studies from the perspective of engineering ethics affords us the opportunity to understand if engineers acted ethically or not in a given situation, what they could have done otherwise, and what they should bear in mind for future case studies regarding ethics. In this article, at first, we draw upon primary and secondary sources in order to analyze two case studies that are of critical importance because, according to the engineers involved in them, it was likely they could have led to fatal accidents. Then, we offer engineering ethics perspectives into the studies. Studying engineering cases from an engineering ethics perspective is crucial for two reasons. First, engineers could have a more completed point of view regarding engineering ethics in order to understand how to act ethically during their work. Second, engineers and others (philosophers of technology, historians of technology, etc.), who analyze these cases in retrospect, could present a more adequate story that would be more useful for the engineers who are taught from it.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Original Articles
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Kline RR. Using history and sociology to teach engineering ethics. IEEE Technology and Society Magazine 2001, 20: 13–20.
Baura GD. Engineering Ethics: An Industrial Perspective. Academic Press, 2006.
Fleddermann CB. Engineering Ethics. 4th ed. Pearson, 2011.
Harris CE, Prichard MS, Rabins MJ. Engineering Ethics: Concepts and Caces. 4th ed. Wadsworth Publishing, 2008.
Martin MW, Schinzinger R. Introduction to Engineering Ethics. McGraw-Hill, 2009.
Nyholm S. This is Technology Ethics: An Introduction. Hales SD (editor) Wiley-Blackwell, 2023.
Peterson M. Ethics for Engineers. Oxford University Press, 2019.
Unger SH. Controlling Technology: Ethics & The Responsible Engineer. 3rd ed. Unger DNS (editor) Independently published, 2017.
van de Poel I, Royakkers L. Ethics, Technology, and Engineering: An Introduction. Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.
Vaughan D. The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA. University of Chicago Press, 1997.
Tsekeris C, Vayena E. The National Commission for Bioethics & Technoethics and the new challenges. Bioethica 2021, 7: 2–4.
IEEE Board of Directors. IEEE Code of Ethics. 2020. (Accessed: 7/12/2023)
Association for Computing Machinery. ACM Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. 2018. (Accessed: 7/12/2023)
National Society of Professional Engineers. Code of Ethics for Engineers. 2019. (Accessed: 7/12/2023)
Kotasek F. CSIT honors former BART engineers. Technology and Society 1978, 6: 1, 3–4.
Roberts J. 3 BART Engineers Fired For Aiding Burfine Inquiries. Contra Costa Times 1972, 58: 1A, 4A.
Unger SH. The BART case: Ethics and the Employed Engineer. IEEE CSIT Newsletter 1973, 1: 6–8.
Roberts J. BART Faces Three Damage Suits. Contra Costa Sunday Times. 1973, 58: 1, 7.
Friedlander GD. The case of the three engineers vs. BART: The outcome of a suit brought by three Bay Area Rapid Transit exemployees may set a historic precedent in the public interest. IEEE Spectrum 1974, 11: 69–77.
Patton C. Board faces first ethics cases under new policy. The Institute 1978, 1, 7–8
Unger SH, Bogumil RJ, Kaufman JS. Dispatching of police cars—A case study. Technology and Society 1978, 6: 3–7.
Lindsay JF. CSIT honors Virginia Edgerton: Award for outstanding service in the public interest presented. Technology and Society 1979, 7: 3–4.
Unger SH, Bogumil RJ, Kaufman JS. Professional Responsibility and the Dispatching of Police Cars - A Case Study. Technology and Society 1978.
Edgerton V. “Adverse Results of Ethical Conduct”. Personal Correspondence with the IEEE CSIT, 1977.
Kowel ST, Elden W, Unger S, Lee F, Zourides V, Thatcher J. Proposed procedures for IEEE support of ethical engineers. Technology and Society 1977, 5: 8–10.
Myers E. Because it was New York. Datamation 1979, 98.