What Testimony Does to Literature


Published: Jul 19, 2021
Keywords:
just art documentary poetics justice Testimony Jean Norton Cru Témoins Primo Levi witnessing
Frédérik Detue
Charlotte Lacoste
Abstract

This article sheds light on a literary practice that critics began to reflect upon in the twentieth century: witnessing. This genre, by adopting a narrative model based on statements of evidence presented in the courtroom, distinguishes itself from other forms of expression practiced by witnesses. Survivors of political violence take up their pens and describe the situation they have been subjected to, so as to attest to historical facts and prevent erasure of the event through forgetting, denial or negation. This enterprise, which seeks to document lived experience and thereby pay homage to victims who did not survive, constitutes both a source of evidence for legal procedure and a contribution to the writing of history. Witnessing, however literary it may be, is founded on a pact of veracity, in which witnesses are bound to relate no more than their own experience and to do so with precision. Finally, witness accounts are addressed to society at large or even to humanity as a whole, in the hope of emancipating it from such violence by raising awareness of its intolerable nature. Though witnessing still lacks legitimacy within the literary field, the link it establishes between ethical, aesthetic and political positions makes this genre exemplary of what literature is capable of.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Articles
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
Author Biographies
Frédérik Detue, Université Côte d’Azur

Frédérik Detue is Senior Lecturer in Comparative Literature at the Université Côte d’Azur, France. A specialist of witnessing in literature and cinema, he has co-edited a special issue of Europe, Témoigner en littérature (January-February 2016) and, over the last five years, has coordinated, in collaboration with Charlotte Lacoste and Judith Lyon-Caen, a seminar entitled “Savoirs du témoignage (Witnessing and knowledge)” at the School for the Advanced Study in Social Sciences (EHESS), Paris. His book Témoigner au cinéma. Une action dans l’histoire will be published in 2021 by the Presses Universitaires de Nanterre.

Charlotte Lacoste, Université de Lorraine

Charlotte Lacoste is Senior Lecturer in French Language and Literature at the Université de Lorraine, France, and member of the CREM (Centre for research on mediations). Her research focuses on witnessing as a literary genre in the 20th and 21st centuries. She has published Séductions du bourreau. Négation des victimes [Seductions of the persecutor, negation of the victims] (Presses universitaires de France, 2010), an essay on the rehabilitation of political mass murderers in contemporary fiction, and she has co-edited, along with Frédérik Detue, a special issue of the journal Europe entitled Témoigner en littérature [Witnessing in Literature]. Since 2016, in collaboration with Frédérik Detue and Judith Lyon-Caen, she has coordinated the “Savoirs du témoignage [Witnessing and knowledge]” seminar at the School for the Advanced Study in Social Sciences (EHESS), Paris.

References
Abensour, Miguel. “Le choix du petit.” Postface to Theodor.W.Adorno, Minima Moralia. Réflexions sur la vie mutilée, Paris: Payot, 1991. 231–243.
Balzac, Honoré de. Preface. La Peau de chagrin. 1831. La Comédie humaine, vol. 10. Études philosophiques. Paris. Gallimard, 1992 : 47–55.
Beledian, Krikor. “Le retour de la Catastrophe.” L’Histoire trouée. Négation et témoignage. Ed. Catherine Coquio. Nantes: L’Atalante, 2003. 299– 328.
—. “Traduire un témoignage écrit dans la langue des autres.” Mémoires du génocide arménien. Héritage traumatique et travail analytique. Eds. Vahram Altounian and Janine Altounian, Paris: P.U.F., 2009. 97–112. http://memoires.ommx.org/book#97
Benjamin, W. (1999) The Arcades Project. Trans. H. Eiland & K. McLauchlin. Cambrigde, MA: Harvard UP.
Bernier, Jean. La Percée. Roman d’un fantassin, 1914-1915. Marseille: Agone, 2004.
Bourdelais, Patrice and Didier Fassin, eds. Les Constructions de l’intolérable. Études d’anthropologie et d’histoire sur les frontières de l’espace moral, Paris: La Découverte, 2005.
Broch, Hermann. “Notes on the Problem of Kitsch.” 1950. Kitsch: The World of Bad Taste. Ed. Gillo Dorfles. London: Studio Vista, 1969.
Chevrier, Jean-François and Philippe Roussin. “Présentation.”
Communications. Le parti pris du document: littérature, photographie, cinéma et architecture au XXe siècle, n° 71, 2001 : 5–11.
Cohen, Marcel. “Faire avec presque rien, ou le métier d’un écrivain stupéfait.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 207–220.
Cru, Jean Norton. Témoins. Essai d’analyse et de critique des souvenirs de combattants édités en français de 1915 à 1928. 1929. Nancy: Presses universitaires de Nancy, 2006.
—. War Books. A Study in Historical Criticism. N.d. TS. BU des Fenouillères - Arts, lettres et sciences humaines (Aix-en-Provence). Odyssée. https://odyssee.univ-amu.fr/files/original/1/452/MS-73_Cru- Norton_War-books.pdf
Detue, Frédérik and Charlotte Lacoste. “Ce que le témoignage fait à la littérature.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 3–15. https://bit.ly/2JByPue.
Detue, Frédérik and Charlotte Lacoste. Eds. “Ce que le témoignage fait à la littérature.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016.
Dorgelès, Roland. Souvenirs sur les Croix de bois. Paris: À la Cité des livres, 1929.
Dulong, Renaud. Le Témoin oculaire. Les conditions sociales de l’attestation personnelle. Paris: Éd. de l’E.H.E.S.S., 1998.
Genevoix, Maurice. Ceux de 14. 1950. Paris: Le Seuil, 2007.
Hallé, Guy. “Là-bas. Avec ceux qui souffrent.” Europe. Témoigner en
littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 16–36.
Hartmann, Marie “Négation et détournement des témoignages concentrationnaires : la trilogie allemande de Louis-Ferdinand Céline.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016: 99- 114.
Hobsbawm, Eric J. Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century, 1914-1991. London: Abacus, 1995.
Jubert, Raymond. Verdun. Mars-avril-mai 1916. 1918, posth. Nancy: Presses universitaires de Nancy, 1989.
Kimpflin, Georges. Le Premier souffle. Un fantassin sur la trouée de Charmes, août-septembre 1914. Paris: Perrin, 1920.
Leperlier, Tristan. “Témoins algériens de la “décennie noire en France.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 178-191.
Les Messagers. Directed by Hélène Crouzillat and Laetitia Tura. The Kingdom / Territoires en marge, 2014, 70 min.
Levi, Primo. “Appendice per l’edizione scolastica di Se questo è un uomo, ” in Primo Levi, Opere, Volume Primo. Torino: Einaudi, 1987. 171–201.
—. Auschwitz Report [1946]. Trans. Judith Woolf. London: Verso, 2015.
—. La Zone grise. Entretien avec Anna Bravo et Federico Cereja, Trans.
M. Rueff. Paris: Payot & Rivages, 2014. 3⁄4. Œuvres. Paris: R. Laffont, 2005.
—. The Complete Works of Primo Levi. Edited by Ann Goldstein. London & New York: Penguin Classics.
—. Si c’est un homme. Trans. M. Schruoffeneger. Paris: Pocket, 2003.
Levi, Primo, Benedetti L. De, Fabio Levi, and Domenico Scarpa. Auschwitz Testimonies, 1945-1986. Trans. Judith Woolf. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2018.
Maupassant, Guy de. “Of ‘The Novel’”. Preface to Pierre et Jean. Trans. Clara Dell. New York: Collier & Son.
Missakian, Chavarche. “La Grande Crise.” Trans. Krikor Beledian. Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 47-59.
Morioka Todeschini, Maya. “Écrire la bombe. Ôta Yôko, Ville des cadavres.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 135–138.
Panh, Rithy. “L’art du survivant, une attitude.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016 : 162–177.
Perec, Georges. “Robert Antelme, or the Truth of Literature.” On Robert Antelme’s The Human Race. Ed. Daniel Dobbels. Trans. Jeffrey Haight. Illinois: Northwestern UP, 2003. 139–152.
Rastier, François “‘L’odeur de la chair brûlée’. Témoignage et mentir-vrai.” Europe. Témoigner en littérature, no. 1041-1042, 2016. 115–134.
—. “Témoignages inadmissibles.” Littérature. Écrire l’histoire, vol. 159, no. 3, 2010. 108–129.
Rivette, Jacques. “De l’abjection.” Cahiers du cinéma, no. 120, 1961 : 54–55. Roy, Michaël. Textes fugitifs. Le récit d’esclave au prisme de l’histoire du livre. Lyon: ENS Éditions / Institut d’histoire du livre, 2018.