The Role of Camel and Donkey Milk in Enhancing Quality Properties and In vitro Antioxidant and Antidiabetic Activity of Strained Yogurt


E Akan
F Yildiz Akgül
AD Karaman
Ö Kınık
S Öğüt
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8863-7249
M Çelebi
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0769-299X
Resumen

With increasing emphasis on health, there has been a growing global demand for functional foods. Due to their various health and therapeutic effects, donkey and camel milk have also gained significance. The number of scientific studies demonstrating the health interests of donkey and camel milk is rising. The potential of these milks to be converted into products needs to be evaluated. In this study, the possibility of using a ratio of 15% and 30% camel and donkey milk together with cow milk in the production of strained yogurt has been evaluated. The physicochemical, microbiological, in vitro antioxidant (ABTS, CUPRAC, DPPH) and antidiabetic (α-glucosidase inhibitory effect) properties of strained yogurts were evaluated during the 21 day of storage. It was observed that camel and donkey milk containing yogurts coalugum were similar to control yogurt. The addition of 30% donkey milk to cow milk significantly shortened the fermentation time (p˂0.05). Throughout the storage period, yogurts containing 15% and 30% donkey milk exhibited the highest levels of lactic acid (p˂0.05). Donkey and camel milk samples had a higher S. thermophilus count on the first day of storage than the control yogurt (p˂0.05). The yeast counts in camel and donkey yogurt samples were not significantly different from those in the control sample (p>0.05). The antioxidant activity of yogurt samples varied depending on the storage period and the method used. At a significance level of p < 0.05, a positive correlation (r = 0.54) between the DPPH and ABTS techniques was observed. Yogurt containing 30% camel milk had significantly higher in vitro antidiabetic activity (p˂0.05). In this study, camel and donkey milk, which are claimed to offer health benefits, could be tested in yogurt manufacturing. In conclusion, these yogurt products can be included in the functional food category by evaluating various health benefits with in vitro and in vivo trials.

Article Details
  • Sección
  • Research Articles
Descargas
Los datos de descargas todavía no están disponibles.
Citas
Asprı M, Economou N, Papademas P (2017) Donkey Milk: An Overview
On Functionality, Technology, And Future Prospects. Food Reviews
International 33(3): 316-333.
Agrawal R, Budania S, Sharma P, Gupta R, Kochar DK, Panwar RB ,
Sahani MS (2007) Zero Prevalence Of Diabetes İn Camel Milk Consuming
Raica Community Of North-West Rajasthan, India. Diabetes
Research And Clinical Practise 76(2): 290-296.
Akan E (2021) An Evaluation Of The In Vitro Antioxidant And Antidiabetic
Potentials Of Camel And Donkey Milk Peptides Released From
Casein And Whey Proteins. Journal Of Food Science And Technology
(10): 3743-3751.
Akan E, Yerlikaya O, Akpınar A, Karagozlu C, Kinik O, Uysal HR (2021)
The effect of various herbs and packaging material on antioxidant
activity and colour parameters of whey (Lor) cheese. International
Journal of Dairy Technology 74(3): 554-563.
Al Kanhal HA, Al HAJ OA (2010) Compositional, Technological And
Nutritional Aspects Of Dromedary Camel Milk. International Dairy
Journal 20(12): 811-821.
Alkurd R, Hanash N, Khalid N, Abdelrahim DN, Khan MAB, Mahrous
L, Radwan H, Naja F, Madkour M, Obaideen K, Abu Shihab K, Faris
M (2022) Effect Of Camel Milk On Glucose Homeostasis İn Patients
With Diabetes: A Systematic Review And Meta-Analysis Of Randomized
Controlled Trials. Nutrients 14(6): 1245.
Anwar I, Khan FB, Maqsood S, Ayoub MA (2022) Camel Milk Targeting
İnsulin Receptor-Toward Understanding The Antidiabetic Effects Of
Camel Milk. Frontiers İn Nutrition 8: 1304.
AOAC (2003) Official Methods Of Analysis (17th Edition). Association
Of Analytical. Washington DC USA
Atwaa EH, Hassan MA, Ramadan MF (2020). Production Of Probiotic
Stirred Yogurt From Camel Milk And Oat Milk. Journal Of Food And
Dairy Sciences 11(9): 259-264.
Barłowska J, Szwajkowska M, Litwińczuk Z (2011) Nutritional Value
And Technological Suitability Of Milk From Various Animal Species
Used For Dairy Production. Compherensive Reviews In Food Science
And Food Safety 10(6): 291-302.
Berhe T, Seıfu E, Kurtu MY (2013) Physicochemical Properties Of Butter
Made From Camel Milk. International Dairy Journal 31(2): 51-54.
Berhe M, Medhaniye Aa, Kahsay G, Bırhane E, Abay M (2017) Essential
Neonatal Care Utilization And Associated Factors Among Mothers İn
Public Health Facilities Of Aksum Town. North Ethiopia, Plos One
(4): E0175902.
De Man JC, Rogosa M, Sharpe ME (1960) A Medium For The Cultivation
Of Lactobacilli. Journal Of Applied Microbiology 23: 130-135.
Desouky O, Dıng N, Zhou G (2015) Targeted And Non-Targeted Effects
Of İonizing Radiatio. Journal Of Radiation Research And Applied
Sciences 8(2): 247- 254.
Dharmısthaben P, Sakure A, Lıu Z, Maurya R, Das S, Basaıawmoıt B.,
Kumarı R, Bıshnoı M, Kondepudı KK, Gawaı KM, Baba WN, Maqsood
S, Hatı S (2023) Identification And Molecular Mechanisms Of
Novel Antioxidative Peptides From Fermented Camel Milk (Kachchi
Breed, India) With Anti‐İnflammatory Activity İn Raw Macrophages
Cell Lines. International Journal Of Dairy Technology 76(1): 111-125.
Eissa EA, Yagoub AEA, Babıker EE, Ahmed IAM (2011). Physicochemical,
Microbiological And Sensory Characteristics Of Yoghurt Produced
From Camel Milk During The Storage. Electronic Journal Of
Environmental Agricultural And Food Chemistry 10(6): 2305-2313.
Ejtahed HS Niasari Naslaji A, Mirmiran P, Zraif Yeganeh M, Hedayati
M, Azizi F, Moosavi Movahedi A (2015) Effect Of Camel Milk On
Blood Sugar And Lipid Profile Of Patients With Type 2 Diabetes:
A Pilot Clinical Trial. International Journal Of Endocrinology And
Metabolism 13(1): E21160.
Ghanbari E, Soltani M, Mohammadi S (2021) Effect Of Using Different
Rates Of Donkey Milk And Cow Milk On Physicochemical, Texture
And Sensory Properties Of Set-Type Yogurt. Food Engineering Research
(70): 1-18.
Gıovanna AP, Tıbo A, Sılvestrı L, Mullenbroıch MC, Costantnı I, Maskara
ALA, Sacconı L, Frasconı P, Pavone FS (2018) Whole-Brain
Vasculature Reconstruction At The Single Capillary Level. Science
Reports 8: 12573.
Gonzales-Fandos E, Gıménez, Me, Olarte C, Sanz S (2000) Effect Of Packaging
Conditions On The Growth And The Quality Characteristics
Of Fresh Mushrooms (Agaricus Bisporus) Stored At İnadequate Temperatures.
Journal Of Applied Microbiology 89(4): 624-632.
Gomes RDDS, Bezerra MDF, Macêdo CS, Olıveıra ILSD, Borba LHF,
Urbano SA, Anaya K, Chagas BME, Andrade Neto JC, Olıveıra JPF,
Rangel AHDN (2022) Chemical Evaluation Of Donkey Milk Yogurt
Mixed With Milk From Different Animal Species. Food Science And
Technology 42: E80521.
Guggısberg D, Cuthbert-Steven J, Pıccınalı P, Butıkofer U, Eberhard
(2009) Rheological, Microstructural And Sensory Characterization
Of Low-Fat And Whole Milk Set Yoghurt As İnfluenced By İnulin
Addition. International Dairy Journal 19(2): 107-115.
Ibrahim AH, Khalifa SA (2015) The Effects Of Various Stabilizers On
Physiochemical Properties Of Camel’s Milk Yogurt. Journal Of American
Science 11(1): 15-24.
Kappeler VE, Sluder RD, Alpert GP (1998) Forces Of Deviance: Understanding
The Dark Side Of Policing. Usa: Waveland Press, Isbn:
-88133-983-0.
Kamal KM, Covvey JR, Dashputre A, Ghosh S, Shah S, Bhosle M, Zacker
CA (2017) Systematic Review Of The Effect Of Cancer Treatment On
Work Productivity Of Patients And Caregivers. Journal Of Managed
Care Specialty Pharmacy 23(2): 136-162.
Kamal-Eldin A, Alhammadi A, Gharsallaoui A, Hamed F, Ghnimi S
(2020) Physicochemical, Rheological, And Micro-Structural Properties
Of Yogurts Produced From Mixtures Of Camel And Bovine
Milks. Nfs Journal 19: 26-33.
Keıpopele K, Seıfu E, Sekwatı-Monang B (2018) Composition And Microbial
Quality Of Donkey Milk Sold İn Gaborone, Botswana. Livestock
Research For Rural Development 30(7): 115.
Khalesı N, Khosravı N, Ranjbar A, Godarzı Z, Karımı A (2017) The Effectiveness
Of Earmuffs On The Physiologic And Behavioral Stability İn
Preterm İnfants. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngol
: 43-47.
Mahmoudı I, Ben Moussa O, Boulares M, Chouaıbı M, Hassouna M
(2022) Novel Probiotic Camel Milk Yogurt Supplemented With İnulin:
Antibacterial, Antioxidant And Antidiabetic Effects. Mljekarstvo
(4): 201-212.
Mustafa E, Bhagıel T, Tabıdı M, Ahmed M (2015) The Effect Of Mixing
Different Percentages Of Cow Milk On The Physiochemical Characteristics
Of Camel Milk Yogurt And The Sensory Evaluation Of Yogurt.
World Journal Of Pharmacy And Pharmaceutical Science 4(9):
-190.
OECD/FAO (2020) OECD-FAO Agricultural Outlook 2020-2029. Paris/
FAO, Rome Oecd Publishing.
Omar H, Amal E, Ahmed M, Hassaan H (2019) Production Of Functional
Bio-Yogurt Made From Camel Milk, Skim Milk Retentate And Fortified
With Sweet Potato Powder. Egyptian Journal Of Agricultural
Research 97(1): 441-457.
Paolıno R, Freschı P, Claps S, Tarrıcone S, Sepe L, Cosentıno C (2022)
Effect Of Donkey Milk Addition On The Acceptability Of Caprino,
A Typical Goat Cheese From Basilicata Region, Italy. International
Journal Of Dairy Technology 75(2): 460-462.
Perna A, Intaglietta I, Simonetti A, Gambacorta E (2015) Donkey Milk
for Manufacture of Novel Functional Fermented Beverages. Journal
of Food Science 80(6): 1352-1359.
Salgado MJG, Ramos MS, Assıs DJ, Otero DM, Olıveıra Rl, Rıbeıro
CVDM, Costa P, Olıveıra CAA (2021) Impact Of Fiber-Rich Donkey
Milk Yogurt On Apparent Viscosity And Sensory Acceptance. Lwt-
Food Science And Technology 145: 111494.
Savaş BS, Akan E (2021) Oat Bran Fortified Raspberry Probiotic Dairy
Drinks: Physicochemical, Textural, Microbiologic Properties, In Vitro
Bioaccessibility Of Antioxidants And Polyphenols. Food Bioscience
: 101223.
Shori AB, Baba AS (2014) Comparative Antioxidant Activity, Proteolysis
And İn Vitro Α-Amylase And Α-Glucosidase İnhibition Of Allium
Sativum-Yogurts Made From Cow And Camel Milk. Journal Of Saudi
Chemical Society 18(5): 456-463.
Soleymanzadeh N, Mırdamadı S, Kıanırad M (2016) Antioxidant Activity
Of Camel And Bovine Milk Fermented By Lactic Acid Bacteria Isolated
From Traditional Fermented Camel Milk (Chal). Dairy Science
& Technology 96: 443-457.
Seıfu E (2023) Camel Milk Products: Innovations, Limitations And Opportunities.
Food Production, Processing And Nutrition 5(15): 1-20.
Shukla P, Sakure A, Maurya R, Bıshnoı M, Kondepudı KK, Das S, Lıu Z,
Padhı S, Raı AK, Hatı S (2023) Antidiabetic, Angiotensin‐Converting
Enzyme İnhibitory And Anti‐İnflammatory Activities Of Fermented
Camel Milk And Characterisation Of Novel Bioactive Peptides From
Lactic‐Fermented Camel Milk With Molecular İnteraction Study. International
Journal Of Dairy Technology 76(1): 149-167.
Senel E, Atamer M, Gursoy A, Oztekin FS (2011) Changes İn Some Properties
Of Strained (Süzme) Goat’s Yoghurt During The Storage. Small
Ruminant Research: 99(2-3), 171-177.
Tak L, Baıs B, Sıngh R, Sıngh S, Nayak T (2018) Assessment Of Probiotic
And Neutraceutical Properties Of Camel Milk Yoghurt. International
Journal Of Current Microbiology And Applied Sciences 7(10): 3351-
Terzaghı BE, Sandıne WE (1975) Improved Medium For Lactic Streptococci
And Their Bacteriophages. Applied Microbiology 29: 807-813.
Vincenzetti S, Santini G, Polzonetti V, Pucciarelli S, Klimanova Y, Polidori
P (2021). Vitamins in Human and Donkey Milk: Functional and
Nutritional Role. Nutrients, 13(5): 1509.
Vincenzetti S, Cammertoni N, Rapaccetti R, Santini G, Klimanova Y,
Zhang J-J, Polidori P (2022) Nutraceutical and Functional Properties
of Camelids’ Milk. Beverages 8(1):12.
Wang L, Wu T, Zhang Y, Yang K, He Y, Deng K, Lıang C, Gu Y (2023)
Comparative Studies On The Nutritional And Physicochemical
Properties Of Yogurts From Cows’, Goats’, And Camels’ Milk Powder.
International Dairy Journal 138: 105542.
Yadav H, Jaın S, Sınha PR (2007) Evaluation Of Changes During The
Storage Of Probiotic Dahi at 7 C. International Journal Of Dairy
Technology 60(3): 205-210.
Yangılar F (2013) As A Potentially Functional Food: Goats’ Milk And
Products. Journal Of Food Nutrition Research 1(4): 68-81.
Yılmaz-Ersan L, Ozcan T, Akpınar-Bayızıt A, Sahın S (2016) The Antioxidative
Capacity Of Kefir Produced From Goat Milk. International
Journal Of Chemical Engineering And Applications 7(1): 22.
Yırmıbesoglu SSS, Ozturk BET (2020). Comparing Microbiological Profiles,
Bioactivities, and Physicochemical and Sensory properties Of
Donkey Milk Kefir And Cow Milk Kefir. Turkish Journal Of Veterinary
& Animal Sciences 44(4): 774-781.
Yildiz-Akgül F (2018). Enhancement of torba yoghurt with whey protein
isolates. International Journal of Dairy Technology 71(4): 898-905.
Artículos más leídos del mismo autor/a