Evaluating and comparing the efficacy of the ‘trans-theoretical model’ and ‘theory of planned behavior’ on smoking cessation. A systematic review of the current literature
Published:
Jan 11, 2022
Keywords:
Smoking Cessation tobacco use change of behavior transtheoritical model theory of planned behavior
Abstract
Introduction: Smoking has been a deadly and disease-linked hazardous habit worldwide, resulting in overall decrease in quality of life. Global numbers are growing and aims on reduction are not met. The application of ‘Trans-Theoretical’ (TTM) and ‘Theory of Planned Behavior’ (TPB) models on smoking may provide assistance on reduction and maintenance.
Aim: Therefore, a systematic review of the current literature took place in order to evaluate and compare the efficacy of TTM and TPB against smoking. The outcome may assist field practitioners in their designs and practice.
Methods: An electronic research was conducted in 5 electronic databases. 3,871 initial titles were located and retrieved. The titles retrieved were then accessed using inclusion/exclusion criteria and then were evaluated using 10 main criteria to answer and meet the research aims.
Results: Research for titles resulted in the inclusion of 10 studies, of which 5 used TTM and 5 TPB as a behavior change model on smoking cessation. The quality and efficacy of papers was almost identical, while only one out of the overall 10 studies was efficient on smoking cessation.
Conclusion: The review may provide some strong implications on low efficacy for both TTM and TPB, while there might be a need for new change-of-behavior models against smoking.Practitioners who design individual interventions against smoking may have to seek for alternative to TTM and TPB models of behavior change.
Article Details
- How to Cite
-
Pilafas, G., Strongylaki, N. P. ., & Menti, D. (2022). Evaluating and comparing the efficacy of the ‘trans-theoretical model’ and ‘theory of planned behavior’ on smoking cessation. A systematic review of the current literature. Health & Research Journal, 8(1), 35–49. https://doi.org/10.12681/healthresj.29194
- Section
- Systemic Review
Copyright notice:
The journal "Health and Research Journal" reserves the rights for copyright of the content of the website and also the copyright of the articles published.
By virtue of their appearance in this journal, the articles are free to be used for non-commercial purposes. However, the articles cannot and must not be used in anyway, published elsewhere or modified without any reference to the author and the first publication of the article.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
World Health Organization. WHO global report on trends in prevalence of tobacco use 2000-2025. Third edition [In-ternet]. Geneva; 2019 p. 121. Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/330221/9789240000032-eng.pdf?ua=1
Marks D, Murray M, Evans B, Estacio E. Health Psychology: Theory, Research and Practice. 2018.
Prochaska JO, DiClemente CC, Norcross JC. In search of how people change. Applications to addictive behaviors. Am Psychol 1992;47(9):1102–14.
Prochaska JO, DiClemente CC. Stages and processes of self-change of smoking: Toward an integrative model of change. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1983;51(3):390–5.
Ajzen I. The Theory of Planned Behavior. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1991;50:179–211.
Evers KE, Prochaska JO, Johnson JL, Mauriello LM, Padula JA, Prochaska JM. A randomized clinical trial of a popula-tion- and transtheoretical model-based stress-management intervention. Health Psychol 2006;25(4):521–9.
Johnson SS, Driskell M-M, Johnson JL, Dyment SJ, Prochas-ka JO, Prochaska JM, et al. Transtheoretical model interven-tion for adherence to lipid-lowering drugs. Dis Manag 2006;9(2):102–14.
Johnson SS, Driskell M-M, Johnson JL, Prochaska JM, Zwick W, Prochaska JO. Efficacy of a transtheoretical model-based expert system for antihypertensive adherence. Dis Manag 2006;9(5):291–301.
Levesque DA, Van Marter DF, Schneider RJ, Bauer MR, Goldberg DN, Prochaska JO, et al. Randomized trial of a computer-tailored intervention for patients with depres-sion. Am J Health Promot 2011;26(2):77–89.
Johnson SS, Paiva AL, Cummins CO, Johnson JL, Dyment SJ, Wright JA, et al. Transtheoretical model-based multiple be-havior intervention for weight management: effectiveness on a population basis. Prev Med 2008;46(3):238–46.
Aveyard P, Lawrence T, Cheng KK, Griffin C, Croghan E, Johnson C. A randomized controlled trial of smoking cessa-tion for pregnant women to test the effect of a transtheo-retical model-based intervention on movement in stage and interaction with baseline stage. Br J Health Psychol 2006;11(Pt 2):263–78.
De Silva W, Awang R, Samsudeen S, Hanna F. A Random-ised Single-Blinded Controlled Trial on the Effectiveness of Brief Advice on Smoking Cessation among Tertiary Stu-dents in Malaysia. J Health Med Inform 2016;7(1):1–9.
Huang C-M, Wu H-L, Huang S-H, Chien L-Y, Guo J-L. Transtheoretical model-based passive smoking prevention programme among pregnant women and mothers of young children. Eur J Public Health 2013;23(5):777–82.
Lawrence T, Aveyard P, Evans O, Cheng K. A cluster ran-domised controlled trial of smoking cessation in pregnant women comparing interventions based on the transtheo-retical (stages of change) model to standard care. Tob Con-trol 2003;12(2):168–77.
Li WHC, Wang MP, Lam TH, Cheung YTY, Cheung DYT, Suen YN, et al. Brief intervention to promote smoking ces-sation and improve glycemic control in smokers with type 2 diabetes: a randomized controlled trial. Sci Rep 2017;7:45902.
Burkholder GJ, Nigg C. Overview of the Transtheoretical Model. In: Promoting exercise and behavior change in old-er adults: Interventions with the transtheoretical model. New York, NY, US: Springer Publishing Co; 2002. p. 57–84.
Evers KE, Prochaska JM, Prochaska JO, Driskell M-M, Cum-mins CO, Velicer WF. Strengths and weaknesses of health behavior change programs on the internet. J Health Psy-chol 2003;8(1):63–70.
Joseph J, Breslin C, Skinner H. Critical perspectives on the transtheoretical model and stages of change. In: Changing addictive behavior: Bridging clinical and public health strategies. New York, NY, US: The Guilford Press; 1999. p. 160–90.
Albarracín D, Johnson BT, Fishbein M, Muellerleile PA. Theories of Reasoned Action and Planned Behavior as Models of Condom Use: A Meta-Analysis. Psychol Bull 2001;127(1):142–61.
Sheeran P, Taylor S. Predicting Intentions to Use Condoms: A Meta-Analysis and Comparison of the Theories of Rea-soned Action and Planned Behavior1. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 1999;29(8):1624–75.
Ajzen I, Driver B. Application of the Theory of Planned Be-havior to Leisure Choice. Journal of Leisure Research 1992 ;24:207–24.
Nguyen MN, Potvin L, Otis J. Regular Exercise in 30- to 60-Year-Old Men: Combining The Stages-of-Change Model and The Theory of Planned Behavior to Identify Determi-nants for Targeting Heart Health Interventions. Journal of Community Health 1997;22(4):233–46.
Conner M, Kirk SFL, Cade JE, Barrett JH. Environmental In-fluences: Factors Influencing a Woman’s Decision to Use Dietary Supplements. J Nutr 2003;133(6):1978S-1982S.
Epton T, Norman P, Dadzie A-S, Harris PR, Webb TL, Sheeran P, et al. A theory-based online health behaviour intervention for new university students (U@Uni): results from a randomised controlled trial. BMC Public Health 2014;14:563.
Hassandra M, Lintunen T, Hagger MS, Heikkinen R, Vanha-la M, Kettunen T. An mHealth App for Supporting Quitters to Manage Cigarette Cravings With Short Bouts of Physical Activity: A Randomized Pilot Feasibility and Acceptability Study. JMIR MhealthUhealth 2017;5(5):e74.
Lakerveld J, Bot SDM, van der Ploeg HP, Nijpels G. The ef-fects of a lifestyle intervention on leisure-time sedentary behaviors in adults at risk: the Hoorn Prevention Study, a randomized controlled trial. Prev Med 2013;57(4):351–6.
Neil-Sztramko SE, Belita E, Levinson AJ, Boyko J, Dobbins M. Evaluation of an online knowledge translation interven-tion to promote cancer risk reduction behaviours: findings from a randomized controlled trial. BMC Cancer 2019;19(1):1138.
Zhao X, White KM, McD Young R. A TPB-Based Smoking Intervention among Chinese High School Students. Subst Use Misuse 2019;54(3):459–72.
Al E, Pratkanis AR, Breckler SJ, Greenwald AG. Attitude Structure and Function. Psychology Press; 1989. 480 p.
Sniehotta F. An Experimental Test of the Theory of Planned Behavior. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being 2009;1(2):257–70.
Sussman R, Gifford R. Causality in the Theory of Planned Behavior. PersSocPsychol Bull 2019;45(6):920–33.
Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D. CONSORT 2010 State-ment: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group ran-domised trials. BMJ 2010;340:1–9.
Harden SM, Gaglio B, Shoup JA, Kinney KA, Johnson SB, Brito F, et al. Fidelity to and comparative results across be-havioral interventions evaluated through the RE-AIM framework: a systematic review. Syst Rev 2015;4(155):1–13.
Riaz M, Lewis S, Naughton F, Ussher M. Predictors of smoking cessation during pregnancy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Addiction 2018;113(4):610–22.
Durks D, Fernandez-Llimos F, Hossain LN, Franco-Trigo L, Benrimoj SI, Sabater-Hernández D. Use of Intervention Mapping to Enhance Health Care Professional Practice: A Systematic Review. Health EducBehav 2017;44(4):524–35.
Roberts NJ, Kerr SM, Smith SMS. Behavioral Interventions Associated with Smoking Cessation in the Treatment of To-bacco Use. Health Serv Insights 2013;6:79–85.
Canga N, De Irala J, Vara E, Duaso MJ, Ferrer A, Martínez-González MA. Intervention study for smoking cessation in diabetic patients: a randomized controlled trial in both clinical and primary care settings. Diabetes Care 2000;23(10):1455–60.
Chau TK, Fong DYT, Chan SSC, Wong JYH, Li WHC, Tan KCB, et al. Misconceptions about smoking in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: a qualitative analysis. J ClinNurs 2015;24(17–18):2545–53.
Luh D-L, Chen H-H, Liao L-R, Chen SL-S, Yen AM-F, Wang T-T, et al. Stages of change, determinants, and mortality for smoking cessation in adult Taiwanese screenees. Prev Sci 2015;16(2):301–12.
Prochaska JO, Velicer WF, Fava JL, Ruggiero L, Laforge RG, Rossi JS, et al. Counselor and stimulus control enhance-ments of a stage-matched expert system intervention for smokers in a managed care setting. Prev Med 2001;32(1):23–32.
Ruggiero L, Redding CA, Rossi JS, Prochaska JO. A stage-matched smoking cessation program for pregnant smok-ers. Am J Health Promot 1997;12(1):31–3.
Chan SSC, Wong DCN, Cheung YTD, Leung DYP, Lau L, Lai V, et al. A block randomized controlled trial of a brief smoking cessation counselling and advice through short message service on participants who joined the Quit to Win Contest in Hong Kong. Health Educ Res 2015;30(4):609–21.
Hjalmarson A, Boëthius G. The effectiveness of brief advice and extended smoking cessation counseling programs when implemented routinely in hospitals. Prev Med 2007;45(2–3):202–7.
Schensul JJ, Begum S, Nair S, Oncken C. Challenges in Indi-an Women’s Readiness to Quit Smokeless Tobacco Use. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2018;19(6):1561–9.
Bolle S, van Weert JCM, Daams JG, Loos EF, de Haes HCJM, Smets EMA. Online Health Information Tool Effectiveness for Older Patients: A Systematic Review of the Literature. J Health Commun 2015;20(9):1067–83.
Chen C-C, Yamada T, Smith J. An Evaluation of Healthcare Information on the Internet: The Case of Colorectal Cancer Prevention. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2014;11(1):1058–75.
Sawesi S, Rashrash M, Phalakornkule K, Carpenter JS, Jones JF. The Impact of Information Technology on Patient En-gagement and Health Behavior Change: A Systematic Re-view of the Literature. JMIR Med Inform 2016;4(1):e1.
Xavier AJ, d’Orsi E, Wardle J, Demakakos P, Smith SG, von Wagner C. Internet use and cancer-preventive behaviors in older adults: findings from a longitudinal cohort study. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2013;22(11):2066–74.
Webb TL, Joseph J, Yardley L, Michie S. Using the internet to promote health behavior change: a systematic review and meta-analysis of the impact of theoretical basis, use of behavior change techniques, and mode of delivery on effi-cacy. J Med Internet Res. 2010 Feb 17;12(1):e4.
Fong AJ, De Jesus S, Bray SR, Prapavessis H. Effect of exer-cise on cigarette cravings and ad libitum smoking follow-ing concurrent stressors. Addict Behav 2014;39(10):1516–21.
Glass TW, Maher CG. Physical activity reduces cigarette cravings. Br J Sports Med 2014;48(16):1263–4.
Chen X, Fang X, Li X, Stanton B, Lin D. Stay Away from To-bacco: A Pilot Trial of a School-Based Adolescent Smoking Prevention Program in Beijing, China. Nicotine Tob Res 2006;8(2):227–37.
Zheng P, Guo F, Chen Y, Fu Y, Ye T, Fu H. A Randomized Controlled Trial of Group Intervention Based on Social Cognitive Theory for Smoking Cessation in China. Journal of Epidemiology 2007;17(5):147–55.
Steinmetz H, Knappstein M, Ajzen I, Schmidt P, Kabst R. How Effective are Behavior Change Interventions Based on the Theory of Planned Behavior? Zeitschriftfür Psychol-ogie 2016;224(3):216–33.
Davey G, McClenahan C, Zhao X. Smoking intention among Chinese youth and implications for health interventions. Asia Pacific Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy 2014;5(1):71–86.
Davey G, Zhao X. ‘A real man smells of tobacco smoke’—Chinese youth’s interpretation of smoking imagery in film. Social Science & Medicine 2012;74(10):1552–9.
Zhao X, Young R-M, White KM. ‘I’m not a smoker…yet’: a qualitative study on perceptions of tobacco control in Chi-nese high schools. BMJ Open 2018;8(4):1–9.
Mansournia MA, Higgins JPT, Sterne JAC, Hernán MA. Bi-ases in randomized trials: a conversation between trialists and epidemiologists. Epidemiology 2017;28(1):54–9.
