The Enlightenment thinker Rousseau and Primo De Rivera: the volonté générale in the service of fascism?


Published: Nov 5, 2021
Keywords:
General Will; Democracy; Populism; Fascism; Enlightenment; Primo De Rivera; Social Contract; Totalitarianism
Myron Zacharakis
Abstract

This article explores the theoretical relationship between the Enlightenment philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau and the Spanish fascist ideologue José Antonio Primo de Rivera. The author argues that while Rousseau is often hailed as a founder of modern democratic principles and popular sovereignty, his concept of the "general will" (volonté générale) contains paternalistic and authoritarian tendencies that were later appropriated by fascist ideologies. By comparing Rousseau's The Social Contract with Primo de Rivera's Battle Speeches, the study analyzes how the fascist appropriation of the "people" as a natural, organic entity mirrors Rousseau's insistence on a "real" will that is independent of individual or majority preferences. The article highlights the transition from Enlightenment rationalism to the populist elitism of fascism, suggesting that the identification of the State with the People and the Leader can find its early justification in Rousseau's framework.

Article Details
  • Section
  • Articles
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Bracher, Karl Dietrich. The Age of Ideologies: A History of Political Thought in the Twentieth Century [Η εποχή των ιδεολογιών: μια ιστορία της πολιτικής σκέψης στον εικοστό αιώνα]. Translated by Giannis Karapapas. Agrinio: Tropi Publications, 2018.
Eco, Umberto. Five Moral Pieces [Πέντε ηθικά κείμενα]. Translated by Anna Papastavrou. Athens: Ellinika Grammata, 1998.
Gentile, Emilio. Fascism: History and Interpretation [Φασισμός: ιστορία και ερμηνεία]. Translated by Evangelos Katsifos. Athens: Asini Publications, 2013.
Haddock, Bruce. A History of Political Thought: From 1789 to the Present [Ιστορία της πολιτικής σκέψης: Από το 1789 μέχρι σήμερα]. Translated by Vasilis Frosynos. Athens: Pataki Publications, 2009.
Hoffmann, Christian, and Joel Birman, eds. A New Reading of Populism: Psychoanalysis and Politics [Μια καινούργια ανάγνωση του λαϊκισμού: ψυχανάλυση και πολιτική]. Translated by Katerina Goula. Athens: Plethron Publications, 2019.
Löwith, Karl. From Hegel to Nietzsche: The Revolution in Nineteenth-Century Thought, Vol. II [Από τον Χέγκελ στον Νίτσε: το επαναστατικό ρήγμα στη σκέψη του δέκατου ένατου αιώνα/τόμος β’]. Translated by Georgia Apostolopoulou. Athens: Gnosi Publications, 1987.
Mudde, Cas, and Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser. Populism: A Very Short Introduction [Λαϊκισμός: μια συνοπτική εισαγωγή]. Translated by Eleni Kotsyfou. Athens: Epikentro Publications, 2017.
Politis, George N. "Social Contract: Cradle of Red and Black Jacobins" [Κοινωνικό συμβόλαιο: λίκνο κόκκινων και μαύρων Ιακωβίνων]. In World Congress Proceedings, Vol. 72: Social Philosophy, edited by Konstantinos Boudouris, 263–264. Athens, 2013. https://www.pdcnet.org/wcp23/content/wcp23_2018_0072_0259_0265.
Rivera, José Antonio Primo de. Speeches of Struggle [Λόγοι μάχης]. Translated by Theodoros Maniatis. Athens: Eleftheri Skepsis, 1983.
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. The Social Contract [Το κοινωνικό συμβόλαιο]. Translated by Vasiliki Grigoropoulou and Albertos Steinhauer. Athens: Polis Publications, 2004.
Most read articles by the same author(s)